Artificial Life Support for Brain-Dead Mothers in Georgia Amid Stringent Abortion Laws
American medical professionals preserve brain-dead expectant mothers through artificial means
Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Email Print Copy Link Share
Following a medical emergency, a pregnant woman in the U.S. state of Georgia is declared brain-dead, yet medical practitioners elect to keep her artificially alive. This decision is due to Georgia's rigid abortion laws, which prevent the termination of a pregnancy.
In the U.S. state of Georgia, a brain-dead pregnant woman, whose family claims was due to strict abortion laws, is being kept alive artificially after a medical emergency. According to reports, the doctors' decision is based on Georgia's stringent abortion legislation. The goal is to buy enough time for the child's birth, potentially making it one of the longest such cases, according to the Associated Press (AP).
According to multiple media outlets, Adriana Smith, a 30-year-old woman, complained of intense headaches and sought medical attention at the Northside Hospital in Atlanta. She was treated medically and discharged. The following morning, her friend awoke due to Smith's pleas for air. Doctors at Emory University Hospital diagnosed a brain hemorrhage, and she was later declared brain-dead, having been in her ninth week of pregnancy at the time.
As reported by the family, the treating physicians stated that they were unable to cease life-sustaining measures due to Georgia's abortion ban, which forbids terminations as soon as a fetal heartbeat can be detected, typically around the sixth week of pregnancy.
Adriana Smith's mother, April Newkirk, told local television station WXIA that her daughter is now in her 21st week of pregnancy. She also reported that the fetus, according to doctors, has fluid in the brain. "She is carrying my grandson. But he might be blind, possibly unable to walk, and may not survive after birth," Newkirk said.
"Her family should have had the right to make decisions about her medical care," cited AP the Pro-Choice activist Monica Simpson. "Instead, they had to endure more traumatic experiences, high medical costs, and continued suffering without finding a solution or making progress towards healing."
The Northside Hospital did not respond to AP's request for a statement. Emory Healthcare, the company responsible for Emory University Hospital, stated that they could not provide a comment due to data protection regulations.
Politics Georgia effectively renders cases like this impossible
Following the U.S. Supreme Court's overturning of Roe v. Wade, Wyoming has passed a law mandating an ultrasound before medication abortion. In a statement, the company explained that it supports its medical professionals in their decisions based on clinical experts' consensus, medical literature, and legal guidelines to create individual treatment plans in line with Georgia's and all other applicable laws.
The safety and wellbeing of our patients remain our top priority.” The company added.
Background:
Georgia's specific abortion laws, particularly House Bill 481 (the "Living Infants Fairness and Equality" Act or the "heartbeat ban"), have led to situations where doctors have kept brain-dead pregnant women artificially alive to allow a fetus to develop and be born. Here are the relevant legal details:
- Georgia enforces a strict abortion ban after about six weeks of pregnancy, which is roughly when a fetal heartbeat can be detected. This law took effect in July 2022 after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade[3][4].
- The law includes a limited exception that allows abortion only if it is necessary to save the life of the pregnant woman. However, brain death is considered legal death, so once a woman is declared brain-dead, she is no longer legally alive, removing the applicability of this exception[1].
- In such cases, medical providers have kept brain-dead pregnant women on life support artificially to sustain the fetus until it can survive outside the womb, given that removing life support would likely cause fetal death[1].
- The hospital and healthcare providers follow medical consensus, legal guidance, and clinical expert advice to comply with Georgia's abortion laws, which effectively mandate continuation of somatic support in brain-dead pregnant women to preserve the fetus[1].
- Exceptions for abortion exist in cases of rape or incest with proof, allowing abortion up to 20 weeks, but these do not cover the case of a brain-dead pregnant woman, where life support is maintained to protect the fetus[3].
In summary, Georgia's law bans abortions after about six weeks except to save the life of the woman—who once legally declared brain-dead is no longer considered alive—leading to court and medical decisions to keep brain-dead pregnant women artificially sustained to allow fetal viability and birth under the state's strict abortion restrictions[1][3][4].
- In the context of Georgia's strict abortion laws, the employment policy of doctors and medical practitioners is influenced by policy-and-legislation, particularly science-based guidelines and legal stipulations.
- The health-and- wellness of both the brain-dead mother and the unborn child are major concerns within the community policy and mental-health discussions in light of the Georgia case.
- Moreover, the women's health implications and potential physical disabilities in the born child, as seen in the Adriana Smith case, are points of contention within the political landscape and policy-and-legislation debates.
- The general-news media outlets often bring up the irony of the situation, where politics leads to controversial decisions that limit individual rights, as highlighted by the ongoing case of a brain-dead pregnant woman in Georgia.
